A work order marked completed doesn't always mean the problem was solved.
Most programs track how fast work orders close. Few track whether the fix held.
Industry average first-time fix rate. Top performers reach 88%, the bottom tier 60%.
Return visits a year for a portfolio running 2,000 work orders at the 77% rate.
Each return visit is a job paid for twice.
Closed is not the same as fixed
First-time fix rate measures how often a problem is resolved on the first visit. According to Aquant's 2026 Field Service KPI Benchmark Report, which analyzed anonymized performance data from 161 service organizations, the industry average is 77%. Top performers reach 88%, and the bottom tier sits at 60%. At the low end, up to 2 in 5 jobs need a return visit.
Most maintenance programs report how quickly work orders close. Speed matters, but a fast close on a repair that did not hold is not a win. It is the same problem, scheduled for later.
Every return visit is paid for twice
For a portfolio running 2,000 work orders a year at the 77% industry rate, roughly 460 jobs need a second visit. Each one usually brings another trip charge, more downtime for the equipment, and another disruption for the people working on site. We looked at those knock-on costs in A maintenance issue costs more than the repair bill.
Return visits also hide in plain sight. When the second visit is logged as a new work order, the first one still shows as completed, and the report looks better than the experience at the location.
Qualified vendor matched to the job
The right trade and the right experience for the equipment, so the first technician on site can finish the job.
Equipment tested after the repair
The unit is run and checked before the technician leaves, not after the next complaint from the location.
Before and after photos
Every job is documented, so you can see what was found, what was done, and what it looked like when the vendor left.
Each vendor's return visits tracked
Repeat visits are tied back to the original job and the vendor who did it, so patterns show up in the data.
The question worth asking
Start with one number: how many of last quarter's closed work orders needed a second visit? If nobody can answer it, return visits are not being tracked, and the vendors with the most of them look the same as the ones who get it right.
Tracking it does not take a new system. Link each return visit to the original work order, use a consistent window (30 days is a common choice), and review the rate by vendor and by trade. Our 60-second maintenance control assessment is a quick way to see where else your program stands.
At Maintina, a job isn't closed until the fix is verified. If return visits are eating into your budget, let's talk.
Source: Aquant, 2026 Field Service KPI Benchmark Report, anonymized performance data from 161 service organizations (February 2026). The 460 figure is illustrative: 2,000 work orders × a 23% return-visit rate.
The cheapest repair is rarely the cheapest outcome.
75% of organizations say procurement hasn't kept pace with their facilities management goals. A low quote wins the bid, but the real cost shows up over the life of the asset.
Read the insight →Maintenance just got more expensive, and it's not anyone's fault.
Maintenance service prices are up 7.55% year over year. On a $500K annual budget, that is roughly $37,750 more, before a single extra repair.
Read the insight →Most organizations don't have a maintenance problem. They have a capacity problem.
Only 54% of scheduled preventive maintenance gets done, and 47% of maintenance leaders report 10+ hours of unplanned downtime every month. Emergencies pull teams away, and planned work slips first.
Read the insight →Want a clearer view of your maintenance spend?
Tell us about your locations and current program. We will follow up directly.
